Family-Owned Since 1961

Mary's Pizza

Old-school pizza made with the same family recipes that started in a garage and became a Lisbon tradition.

Call To Order Explore Menu
Scroll

Our Story

The Passion For Pizza

Mary's Pizza began in 1961 when Mary Spadero started selling pizza from her garage using hand-crafted family recipes. Over the years, her husband Carmen, daughter Rosiland, and grandsons Steven and Michael helped grow the shop while keeping the flavors and methods that made it special.

In 2000, the family expanded into a larger space, added wings and new menu items, and continued serving the same style of pizza the community fell in love with decades ago.

Mary's Pizza mural celebrating Lisbon, Ohio and the shop's roots since 1961

Menu Highlights

From Classics To Crowd Favorites

The full menu includes pizzas, sides, sandwiches, salads, lunch pies, and party options.

Pizza

Choose thin or thick crust, then build from Mary's signature sauces.

  • Original Mary's Sauce
  • Mary's Marinara
  • Whole Tomato Sauce
  • White Pizza
  • Pepperoni Roll

Original Mary's Sauce is the classic house sauce made with ground sausage.

Mary's Marinara is the meatless option.

Sides

  • Chicken Wings
  • Cheese Sticks
  • Jalapeno Poppers
  • Onion Rings
  • Large Sampler

Sandwiches

  • Focaccia
  • Grinders
  • Italian Sub
  • Muffaletta Sandwich
  • Meatball Sandwich
  • Fish Sandwich
  • Hot Sausage Sandwich

Soups & Salads

  • Chicken Salad
  • Crispy Chicken Salad
  • Buffalo Chicken Salad
  • Chef Salad
  • Tossed Salad
  • Wedding Soup

Party Options & Catering

Larger-format favorites for banquets, graduation parties, showers, receptions, and group pickup orders.

  • Party Salad
  • Party Focaccia
  • Wing Tray
  • Ask about large-group ordering
See Full Menu

Ask in-store for current pricing, daily specials, and larger party orders.

Fundraisers

Raise Money With Mary's Pepperoni Rolls

Mary's 8-inch pepperoni rolls are packed with original marinara, provolone, and sliced Italian pepperoni. They are wrapped for freshness and built for easy fundraising.

Buy at $3.50 and resell at $7.00 to quickly support your team, class, club, or event.

Call For Details
Mary’s Pizza fundraiser food display

Location

Come Grab A Pizza

301 North Beaver St.
Lisbon, Ohio 44432

330-424-3559
maryspizza330@gmail.com

Get Directions Facebook

Hours

Opening Hours

  • Tuesday3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed

Holiday hours may vary throughout the year, so call ahead for special schedules.

Quick Answers

Helpful Details Before You Order

Fast answers about location, hours, cook times, crust options, party trays, and fundraiser ordering.

Where is Mary's Pizza located?

Mary's Pizza is at 301 North Beaver St., Lisbon, Ohio 44432, with easy pickup access in town.

What are the hours?

The shop is open Tuesday through Saturday from 3:00 PM to 10:00 PM and closed Sunday and Monday. Holiday hours may vary, so it is best to call ahead.

What crust and sauce options are available?

Mary's Pizza offers thin or thick crust. Original Mary's Sauce is the classic house sauce made with ground sausage, while Mary's Marinara is the meatless option.

How long does it take for pizzas to cook?

Plan on about 45 minutes for Mary's pizzas to cook, especially during busy pickup times.

Are party trays or larger pickup orders available?

Yes. Party salad, party focaccia, and wing trays are available for showers, graduations, receptions, and other group orders.

Does Mary's Pizza offer fundraiser items?

Yes. Pepperoni rolls are set up for school, team, club, and event fundraising with simple pickup and resale options.